Threads of Violence and Faith
Context:
In the proximity of the nation’s capital, the Nuh district of Haryana has become a stage for a recurring narrative of violence, juxtaposed against religious events that were once markers of communal cohesion. The phenomenon of religious processions has evolved from a platform of shared piety into a theater of brazen aggression.
Relevance:
GS – 02 (Fundamental Rights, Indian Constitution)
GS – 01 (Indian society- Communalism)
Prelims:
- Freedom of Religion
- Article 25-28
- Fundamental Rights
- NIA
- CBI
- Forceful Conversion.
Mains Question:
- Discuss the factors behind the evolution of religious processions from symbols of communal harmony to vehicles of aggression, drawing upon recent instances in Nuh district, Haryana. (150 words)
Dimensions of the Article:
- The Catalysts of Violence
- A New Normal: Open Collusion and Brazenness
- The Unpredictable Play of Provocation
- Changing Dynamics of Communal Dynamics
- The Resonance of History
- The Shadows of Modernity
- From Unseen Margins to the Frontlines
The Catalysts of Violence:
- In a comprehensive report titled “Routes of Wrath: Weaponising Religious Processions,” a consortium of independent professionals outlined the intricate web of factors that propelled violence across nine States during the observances of Ram Navami and Hanuman Jayanti.
- Senior advocate Chander Uday Singh underscored the consistent catalysts driving these upheavals – religious processions followed by targeted assaults on Muslim-owned establishments and places of worship.
A New Normal: Open Collusion and Brazenness:
- The contemporary landscape witnesses a departure from the past, where “culpable amnesia” served as a veil for authorities’ involvement in communal violence.
- Presently, local administrations openly align with riotous mobs, negating the need for covert incompetence. The violence is often orchestrated, marked by exposed weaponry, ear-piercing music, and provocative slogans, while measured restraint is observed from the other side.
The Unpredictable Play of Provocation:
- Nuh district, despite its calm façade over two years, encountered a shift during the Brajmandal Jalabhishek Yatra, attributed to the involvement of a notorious cow vigilante.
- This individual, wanted for murder in a neighboring state, operated unhindered under the protection of Haryana’s police.
- Gandhi’s observations from 1924 gain renewed significance, as tensions arising from cow slaughter and musical provocations are replaced by more complex triggers.
Changing Dynamics of Communal Dynamics:
- The social fabric of Nuh and the larger Mewat region diverges from the norm.
- The Meo community, drawing inspiration from the Brindavan region, holds diverse traditions and practices.
- Despite communal tensions, the Meo remained focused on shared interests across faiths. Historically, the Congress party’s “Muslim mass contact” program sought to bridge communal divides, fostering identities based on shared material concerns.
The Resonance of History:
- Mewat’s history, linked to princely states and the Congress party’s efforts, reveals deep-seated grievances that shaped the region.
- Acts of violence against the Meo community left indelible scars, suppressed by the consolidation of nationalist sentiment.
- This silence concealed atrocities, a “sociability” imposed by the magnitude of violence.
The Shadows of Modernity:
- Nuh’s emergence as Haryana’s only Muslim-majority district is marred by disparities in development.
- While Gurgaon thrives on urbanization, Nuh lingers in stagnation. The National Family Health Survey highlights discrepancies, indicating lower female literacy rates and educational opportunities.
- Nuh’s relegation to the margins perpetuates cycles of neglect and resentment.
From Unseen Margins to the Frontlines:
- The contestation of faith in Nuh emerges from the assertion of Hindutva forces.
- Empowered and emboldened, these forces push the boundaries of religious authority.
- The Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) propels a narrative that endeavors to legislate religious practices nationwide, transforming assertions into accepted truths.
Conclusion and the way forward:
- The transformation of religious processions from a source of communal harmony to a theater of violence stems from a complex interplay of historical grievances, political machinations, and emerging ideologies.
- The current scenario underscores the need for inclusive policies that address disparities, mitigate grievances, and foster genuine interfaith understanding.
- As the nation’s constitutional fabric navigates these tumultuous waters, ensuring the prevalence of law and order over vigilantism becomes a critical pursuit.
- The journey from tradition to turmoil necessitates a recalibration of priorities, forging a new trajectory towards peace and harmony.
