Little has changed in the Income-Tax Bill, 2025
Context
Recently, the Union Finance Minister introduced the Income-Tax Bill, 2025. The new bill proposes to replace the old Income-Tax Act, 1961.
Relevance:
GS-02 (Government policies and interventions)
Key highlights:
- With the introduction of the new bill, the government aims to reduce the burden by simplifying tax laws.
- The new bill offers to provide better readability through consolidation of various provisions into tables and schedules in which certain outdated provisions are removed.
- The new bill has also brought in reforms in certain definitions, making it crisp and easy to understand.
- The bill empowers tax authorities’ to search and seize assets.
Key Changes in the Income-Tax Bill, 2025
- Minimal Simplification of Legal Language: Words like “notwithstanding anything contained to the contrary,” “irrespective of anything to the contrary,” etc., have been removed to make it more accessible to the common taxpayer.
- Continuation of Existing Legal Framework: Several provisions still reference the 1961 Act, making the Bill more of a restructuring exercise rather than a reform.
- Enhanced Search and Seizure Powers: It explicitly allows officials to inspect electronic devices, social media accounts, emails, and digital storage—a significant departure from the existing law.
- There is no judicial oversight on these powers, raising privacy concerns in light of the Supreme Court’s verdict in K.S. Puttaswamy vs. Union of India (2017), which upheld the fundamental right to privacy.
- Litigation and Uncertainty: Many provisions retain their litigious nature, as courts have already interpreted the 1961 Act’s provisions over decades. The new Bill rearranges rather than resolves these contentious sections, which could lead to more disputes instead of reducing them.
Significance of the Bill
- Modernized Tax Laws: The Bill aims to consolidate compliance and reorganise tax provisions.
- Maintaining Revenue Collection Efficiency: While the structure has changed, the government ensures that taxation policies remain largely unchanged to maintain revenue inflow.
Challenges:
- Concerns Over Expanded Executive Powers: The new search-and-seizure provisions could have serious privacy implications in an era of digital communication.
- Limited Impact on Taxpayer Experience: The bill does little to simplify tax compliance for ordinary taxpayers.
Way Forward
- The government must prioritize plain-language drafting to make tax laws more accessible and reduce litigation.
- Instead of a mere restructuring exercise, tax laws should focus on simplifying procedures, reducing exemptions, and creating a fairer tax regime.
Mains Question:
Discuss the challenges arising in simplifying tax laws in India. (150 words)
Related Posts
Urban Flooding
Posted on
