Impeachment of Judges

Why in the News?

The Opposition in Rajya Sabha is preparing to move a motion for impeachment of Allahabad High Court Judge for his controversial remarks inciting communal hatred.

Impeachment Process for Judges in India

About
  • The process involves Parliament passing an address to the President to remove the judge.
  • To pass the motion, twothirds of the MPs present and voting in both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha;
    • Must approve it, with a majority of more than 50% of the total membership of each House.
Key Constitutional Provisions
  • Article 124(4): The judge can only be removed by a Presidential order, passed after a majority vote in both Houses of Parliament.
  • The vote must come from two-thirds of the members present and voting.
  • Articles 218 of the Constitution extends the same rules to High Court judges.
  • The impeachment process ensures judicial independence by maintaining a high bar for removal, limiting political influence.
Grounds for Impeachment
  • A judge of the Supreme Court or High Court can be impeached on two grounds“proved misbehaviour” or “incapacity” as per the Constitution of India.
  • Further clarified in the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, including:
    • Misuse of office
    • Grave offences that undermine the judge’s integrity
    • Contravention of the provisions of the Constitution.
What does the process entail? Procedure under the Judges Inquiry Act, 1968:

Initial Step: The impeachment motion must be signed by at least 100 MPs in the Lok Sabha and 50 MPs in the Rajya Sabha.

Committee Formation: Once the motion is introduced, the Speaker or Chairperson of the respective House forms a three-member inquiry committee:

  1. Headed by the Chief Justice of India or a Supreme Court judge.
  2. The second member is usually a Chief Justice of any High Court.
  3. The third member is a distinguished jurist, appointed by the Speaker or Chairman.

Inquiry Process: The committee investigates the charges, cross-examines witnesses, and regulates its procedure.
The committee may also request a medical test if the charge relates to mental incapacity.

Outcome: If the committee finds the judge not guilty, the motion is dismissed. If found guilty, it will be reported back to the House for further action.

Instances of Impeachment in India

  • 1993: Justice V Ramaswami (Supreme Court) faced impeachment proceedings on financial impropriety. The motion was unsuccessful despite a guilty finding.
  • 2011: Justice Soumitra Sen (Calcutta High Court) was impeached for corruption but resigned before Lok Sabha could take up the matter.
  • 2015: Justice S K Gangele (Madhya Pradesh High Court) faced impeachment on charges of sexual harassment, but the committee cleared him in 2017.
  • 2015: Justice J B Pardiwala (Gujarat High Court) faced impeachment for controversial remarks about reservation but the motion was dropped after the judge expunged the remarks.
  • 2017: Justice C V Nagarjuna (Andhra Pradesh & Telangana High Court) faced impeachment for financial misconduct and victimizing a Dalit judge, but the motion was not pursued.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *